Dinner with the Godfather

Last week, we made our foodies an offer they couldn’t refuse – ‘Dinner with the Godfather‘. The setting at Caffe Sicilia was eerily reminiscent of Louis’ Restaurant in the scene where Michael Corleone takes out Sollozzo and McKlucksy. Fortunately for us, on this occasion everybody made it out alive. Mafia references aside, we enjoyed a complete feast, indulging in five courses of authentic Sicilian delicacies.

An uncanny resemblance...



An Aperol spritzer was presented on arrival, a refreshing apretif to tickle the tastebuds and prepare us for what was to come. Lovely and aromatic herbed bread awaited us at the tables, accompanied by a fragrant olive oil and balsamic vinegar. The feast began, and first course kicked off with a pumpkin and Sicilian pecorino flan served with honey and walnuts. The crust-less tart was presented next to a subtle sweet pumpkin puree, which went perfectly with the combination of honey and walnuts.

Aperol spritz

Herbed bread with olive oil and balsamic vinegar

Pumpkin and Sicilian pecorino flan served with honey and walnuts
Next to arrive was my personal favourite, the San Daniele wrapped prawns on a bed of confit garlic and balsamic reduction. Big juicy prawns tasted sweet inside the salty prosciutto, complemented by the smooth and subtle confit garlic. The balsamic reduction added a touch of piquancy, rounding out the flavours in the dish.

San Daniele wrapped prawns on a bed of confit garlic and balsamic reduction
Lobster ravioli dressed in a light thyme and seafood bisque and cherry tomatoes followed its crustacean cousins. Chewy parcels filled with generous chunks of lobster were served with a sweet tomato puree and light bisque.

Lobster ravioli dressed in a light thyme and seafood bisque and cherry tomatoes
The final savoury course delivered a seared fanned 30 day aged sirloin steak with a burnt rosemary and green peppercorn oil served with Lyonnaise potatoes. The dry aged steak was cooked rare, seared lightly on the outside to seal in juices, the centre of each slice was pink and soft. The rosemary and peppercorn oil added subtle fragrant accents to the flavour of the beef.

Seared fanned 30 day aged sirloin steak with a burnt rosemary and green peppercorn oil served with Lyonnaise potatoes
After a bit of seat shuffling to help to mix up our rather large group, we settled down with dessert - Sicilian chocolate cheesecake with a sweet orange glaze. The light cake sandwiched a layer of cream and nuts and was topped with a healthy coating of chocolate. The orange glaze added a citrus zing to the chocolate and cream flavours. It was a little dry though and lacked the spunk and flavour Sicilia’s pastries usually offer. A glass of Frangelico and lime was the perfect digestif, the fragrant hazelnut aroma of the liqueur with the tartness of fresh lime ended our meals on a divine note.

Sicilian chocolate cheesecake with a sweet orange glaze
Caffe Sicilia is an authentic Sicilian restaurant with quality food and friendly (to say the least!) service. Ladies, watch out for those cheeky Italian waiters and the naughty desserts in the deli counter. But enough about what I think, let’s hear what our foodies had to say…






628 Crown Street
Surry Hills, Sydney
NSW 2010
(02) 9699 8787
www.caffesicilia.com.au
Did you know we do corporate and private events at Secret Foodies? A little jealous of our event? Shoot us an email to find out how you can host your own ‘Dinner with the Godfather’ for your friend or colleagues. msdarlinghurst@secretfoodies.com.au
Category: East






The food were delicious. However ravioli was a bit too al dente for my liking but flavor of lobster was just divine! Their intense wine list is definitely something to look in to! Ask the friendly staff and they certain know whats what! I got to sit near the dessert section, so I was drooling throughout the entire night! Lovely atmosphere! I’d come back and bring companies with me!
Cute, old school Italian restaurant – nice food but there is a language barrier with the wait staff
So well orchestrated and curated….great food…great spirit among people…loved it!
Fantastic flavors, great company and funky surroundings! Definitely be back for more!
Very well organized, great to see people doing something out of their comfort zone. Great benue @CaffeSicilia. Favourite dish prawns wrapped in prosciutto. Looking forward to the next one.
Fantastic night. Excellent food drank an Italian Barbera wonderful! Steak was very tender – succulent & superb. Bon Appetite!!! The Pinot also helped everything go down. Grazie.
Wonderful food, wonderful evening with fantastic food and fantastic company. Thanks Alex and cafe sicilia!
Secret Foodies was great fun, I even enjoyed being cajoled into moving seats and having a mingle. Paulo was a dude.
Great night. Much better than expected. Paulo is awesome.
Awesome evening
Awesome food
Secret Foodies rocks
Caffe siciliana rocks
Great night! Lovely staff and enjoyed the food
Had a stunning evening! Good food, great wine and beautiful company! Service was very attentive and warm….would definitely come again!
Bellissimo!
We came for our first secret Foodies event to celebrate my girlfriends birthday and had a very memorable and fun evening – with amazing food needless to say. With a diverse crowd and great food I very much recommend giving it a go.
Great food. Good company. Dessert was too heavy and big though. Loved the frangelico on ice.
People – fantastic
Entree – fantastic
Main – fantastic
Dessert – fail
Wonderful friendly staff, but overall a little bit of an underwhelming experience. The prawns were great, but the ravioli, steak and dessert were all a disaster. Love the concept of secret foodies but think they missed the mark, cafe sicilia isn’t too secret and didn’t think the dinner matched the price tag .
What a lovely dining experience – shared tables and conversations – no strangers just friends you haven’t met yet, ably hosted by the gorgeous Alex and Donna! I’ll be back for sure
In order to license music, hybrid cars write and provide better ones.
This is where the personalized music for kids will be.
Mr Frawley believes that 15 time can be too long. All other than strength customers also need time for maintain the the right time.